Our Hours

Sunday - Thurdsay 11AM - 10PM

Friday & Saturday 11AM - 11PM

231 Aurora Street • Lancaster, NY 14086

The Pizza Heist in Lancaster

A Meal for a Steal!

The Heist Brothers at Work

The Pizza Heist is the restaurant to get a meal for a steal in Lancaster, NY. Since 2012, we’ve been creating gourmet pizzas you won’t find just anywhere—try our Rodeo Pizza, topped with onion rings! No matter what day or time you’re craving our pizza, chance are we’re open. For lunch or dinner, we have meals your whole family can enjoy. Call ahead or walk in; we offer takeout and delivery.

In addition to pizzas, we have a tasty selection of subs, tacos, salads, wraps, dinner plates, and appetizers. Our cooks work with fresh ingredients to deliver high quality food and impeccable service daily. We participate in local events to connect with our community, including the annual Taste of Lancaster, where took home a 1st place plaque 2 years in a row. If you’re looking for delicious pizza to enjoy as a hot meal at home or at an upcoming event, stop in The Pizza Heist—we’ll take care of you!

231 Aurora StreetLancaster, NY 14086716.681.1111info@thepizzaheist.com