Our Hours

Sunday - Thurdsay 11AM - 10PM

Friday & Saturday 11AM - 11PM

231 Aurora Street • Lancaster, NY 14086

The Pizza Heist in Lancaster Menu

The Pizza Heist has a diverse menu of Italian and American favorites, with daily specials Monday through Friday. We also offer combos which include pizzas, subs, and wings. With over 16 different pizzas, you’re sure to find something you’ll love. Try our Stinger Pizza, with steak and chicken fingers under lettuce and tomato. Our Lancaster pizza restaurant offers several hot and cold subs, along with wraps. Our tacos are delicious and our appetizers are unique—try our funnel cake fries. Salads are also available. Browse our full menu below and be careful not to drool while you place an order!

View Menu

231 Aurora StreetLancaster, NY 14086716.681.1111info@thepizzaheist.com